Download e-book for iPad: Debating Scotland. Issues of independence and union in the by Michael Keating
By Michael Keating
On 18 September 2014, Scotland held a referendum at the query: may still Scotland be an self sufficient state? this can be a most original occasion in glossy democracies and engaged the political classification, civil society, and most of the people to an exceptional measure, resulting in an eighty five consistent with cent turnout within the ultimate vote. This used to be an celebration to discuss not only the slender constitutional factor however the way forward for the nation, together with the financial system, social welfare, defence and protection, and Scotland's position in Europe and the realm. Debating Scotland comes from a staff of researchers who saw the debates from close-up and engaged with either side, with the media and with the general public in examining the problems, whereas closing impartial at the independence query. The e-book examines the most matters at stake, how they have been awarded, and the way they developed over the process the crusade. The editors and contributing authors discover the methods either independence and union have been framed, the industrial concerns, the forex, welfare, defence and safeguard, the eu Union, and the way the instance of small autonomous states was once used. the quantity concludes with an research of voter responses, established upon unique survey learn, which demonstrates how perceptions of possibility and uncertainty at the major concerns performed a key function within the outcome. Read more...
Read Online or Download Debating Scotland. Issues of independence and union in the 2014 referendum PDF
Best public policy books
One of many largest issues of smooth democracy is that the majority of the general public is mostly blind to politics and govt. usually, many folks take into account that their votes are not likely to alter the end result of an election and don't see the purpose in studying a lot approximately politics. this can be rational, however it creates a state of individuals with little political wisdom and little skill to objectively assessment what they do understand.
Lynn argues that the condemnation of eugenics within the moment half the twentieth century went too some distance and provides a reassessment. The eugenic targets of doing away with genetic illnesses, expanding intelligence, and decreasing character issues he argues, stay fascinating and are possible by means of human biotechnology.
Many nations all over the world block or filter out net content material, denying entry to information—often approximately politics, but additionally when it comes to sexuality, tradition, or religion—that they deem too delicate for usual electorate. entry Denied records and analyzes web filtering practices in over 3 dozen international locations, providing the 1st conscientiously performed examine of this accelerating pattern.
As of the longest serving major ministers in Europe, Tony Blair and Bertie Ahern have been in energy in the course of some of the most tumultuous sessions of eu integration. This booklet bargains a special and engaging perception into how they answered to the calls for and possibilities of eu Union club on the nationwide point.
- Economic Analysis, Moral Philosophy and Public Policy (2nd Edition)
- The Hybrid Media System: Politics and Power
- Sudan: Race, Religion, and Violence
- The Hybrid Media System: Politics and Power
- Rebalancing Society: Radical Renewal Beyond Left, Right, and Center
Additional resources for Debating Scotland. Issues of independence and union in the 2014 referendum
The ﬂurry of claims and statistics on both sides created a great deal of confusion, but the issue tended to work to the beneﬁt of No, if only because it raised levels of risk and uncertainty. On the other hand, a strong emphasis on the dire economic consequences of independence could come across as threatening and unduly negative, implicitly suggesting that Scots were incapable of managing their own affairs. It also risked identifying No with big business; the association was reinforced at the end of the campaign when, faced with polls showing Yes to be ahead, there was an orchestrated intervention by big ﬁrms, banks, and even some supermarkets warning of calamitous consequences should there be a Yes vote.
In other words, there was no ofﬁcial body holding the ring to set a neutral framework. Given the political nature of the decision, it was unavoidable that the issues should be framed in an adversarial manner. What was lacking, from an economics perspective, was a basic plan of how the economy would develop with and without the fundamental changes that would accompany independence. On the Yes side, one major lever that an independent country could have—the ability to run an independent monetary policy, with the attendant power to set interest rates and have a ﬂexible exchange rate—was ruled out.
There was a large amount of information uncovered and much discussion, but the debate took the form of advocacy, rather than an attempt to reach agreed cost and beneﬁt ﬁgures. The White Paper from the Scottish Government reads more like a Yes campaign election manifesto than a document setting out the alternatives for an extremely important constitutional decision. The non-neutral tone can be assessed from the very ﬁrst page where, after a very brief account of the advantages of having the governance of Scotland solely in the hands of the Scottish Government, the document states: ‘This is what being independent can deliver for Scotland and it is why the Scottish Government believes the people of Scotland, individually and collectively, will be better off with independence’ (Scottish Government, 2013f: i).
Debating Scotland. Issues of independence and union in the 2014 referendum by Michael Keating