Never confuse arrogance with confidence
August, 2010In ancient Greece, Alcibiades was telling Pericles how Athens should be governed. Annoyed by the young man's tone and manner, Pericles said, "Son, when I was your age, I talked just the way you are talking."
Alcibiades looked Pericles in the face and replied, "How I should like to have known you when you were at your best."
Ah, the arrogance of youth. To put the story in context, Pericles is often referred to as "the first citizen of Athens" for his many achievements: his promotion of art and literature, his championing of democracy, and his sponsorship of an ambitious building project that included most of the surviving structures on the Acropolis, including the Parthenon. Alcibiades, on the other hand, was also a statesman and orator, but his encyclopedia entry is only a few lines.
And in the dictionary, Alcibiades could define "hubris."
Hubris means extreme haughtiness, exaggerated pride or arrogance. Hubris often indicates being out of touch with reality and overestimating one's own competence or capabilities, especially for people in positions of power.
As I've written many times before, arrogance is one of the deadliest of human failings and can destroy a business or a career. Today's headlines illustrate hubris to the extreme: the disgraced governor of Illinois trying to defend his actions . . . the CEO of BP complaining just days after the oil rig explosion and resulting massive oil spill that he wanted his life back . . . the teenage "barefoot bandit" who was finally captured three years into a crime spree after he crashed a stolen airplane.
All are examples of losing touch with the real world, of assuming they were above scrutiny and that somehow their actions were acceptable. Because all had enjoyed a measure of success, they assumed people would give them a pass. They had hubris.
What a difficult lesson they all learned. They confused confidence with arrogance. Confidence in one's ability is a critical element in the willingness to take risks while still steering the ship. Arrogance takes risks by assuming everyone will get on board even when the boat has a hole in it.
How do you know when you're getting arrogant? When the only people you care to listen to or deal with are either at your own level or above it. BP Chairman Carl-Henric Svanberg added fuel to the oil-spill fire with his comment that, "We care about the small people." Whether lost in translation or arrogance personified, his language managed to insult the people he purported to care about.
He could have benefitted from the advice of the late Sam Walton, founder of Wal-Mart. He said, "If we ever get carried away with how important we are because we're a great big $50 billion chain -- instead of one store in Blytheville, Arkansas, or McComb, Mississippi, or Oak Ridge, Tennessee -- then you can probably close the book on us."
As the saying goes, nothing is so hard to do gracefully as getting off your high horse.
Early in the development of flight, the Wright brothers (Orville and Wilbur) were largely dismissed at home in America, and had to go abroad to get proper recognition for their aeronautical achievements.
The French government gave the brothers an opportunity to demonstrate what they had done. But the French were obviously jealous of the two modest Americans.
At a banquet in Paris to honor the accomplishments of the two Wright brothers, the chief speaker at the dinner devoted most of his remarks to claiming that France had led the world in aviation exploration and would do so in the future. However, he said very little in praise of the two American guests.
When Wilbur Wright was called upon to speak, he said: "I am no hand at public speaking, and so I must on this occasion content myself with a few words. As I sat here listening to the speaker who preceded me, I heard his comparisons made to the eagle, to the swallow, and to the hawk as typifying skill and speed in mastery of the air. But somehow or other, I could not keep from thinking of the parrot which, of all the ornithological kingdom is the poorest flier and the best talker."
Clearly, hubris didn't fly with Wilbur Wright.
Mackay's Moral: Hubris is an odd affliction. It makes everyone else sick.
Your TXNP Weekly E-Newsletter is made possible by the generosity of: